State Legislatures Update
By the end of May only 18 states will still be left in their regular sessions. However, this doesn’t mean the bills considered this year are dead; most states will automatically carry legislation over to 2018 as well as any special sessions called between now and then.
You can keep up with which bills are on track to pass this session (or may come back for the next) with ISRI’s State Legislative Tracking System</a>; contact Danielle Waterfield or Justin Short if you have any questions about the bills or the system. ReMA has also added issue specific bill snapshots on the State Policy Resources page along with updates to the metals theft summaries and other resources.
Issue: Metals Theft
Revisions to ISRI’s Position on Recyclable Materials Theft were passed during the Spring Board Meeting in New Orleans. The revised position tightens and refocuses the document to urge recyclers to comply with state and local law and work in cooperation with their communities and law enforcement to inform them about the scrap recycling industry and fight the theft of recyclable materials through methods such as ScrapTheftAlert.com. This and other positions and policies updated during the Board Meeting are available on ISRI’s White Papers, Reports, and Analysis page.
In the states, Maryland added “cell tower batteries” to their list of Used Articles; Oklahoma tweaked the information required for purchases of vehicles by Scrap Metal Dealers; Kentucky changed the registration agency to the Department of Professional Licensing, and Arizona clarified that the auxiliary container laws passed last year do not prevent local business licensing of Scrap Metal Dealers. Several more far-reaching amendments such as Kansas HB 2153, delaying the reporting and database requirements until 2019, are pending passage as of the time of writing; if any are passed, they will be added to the State Metals Theft Law Database and the state summaries available on the Resources page.
Issue: Paper and Plastic Bag Ban Pushback
Following the approval of California‘s bag ban by referendum and the continued push for such bans at the local level, states are beginning to split dramatically in their handling of these bans and fees. While Maine LD 57, currently awaiting action by the governor, encourages local governments to pass their own requirements (in contrast to the original text which would have banned plastic bags), bills passed in Iowa, Kentucky, and New York this session and currently being considered in Minnesota and other states instead prohibit local bans on bags and other containers. This debate between bans and fees vs auxiliary container protections is unlikely to be settled this session, but to date California’s statewide ban remains unique.
States are also working to distinguish “biodegradable” bags due to the problems they can cause when incorrectly added to the recycling stream. Maryland just passed HB 1349, requiring ASTM standards be met for biodegradable plastics and that such products be labeled.
Issue: Electronics
Illinois continues pushing to allow landfilling of CRT glass while also banning accreditation organizations such as SERI from penalizing companies that do so with Illinois HB 772 / SB 774 as well as several attendant House and Senate resolutions. While the Illinois legislature is set to adjourn at the end of May, as of May 8, the House bill had already passed into the Senate and both versions are up for consideration by the Environment and Conservation Committee, while HR 161, HR 108, SR 128, and SR 170 are targeted at urging SERI and e-Stewards to allow storage cells and landfill aggregate as “beneficial use”. Even beyond the issue of placing CRT glass “in storage cells for future retrieval”, these bills represent a direct assault on the ability of accreditation organizations to operate independently and determine standards. Also in Illinois, HB 3881 would require recyclers and refurbishers to submit quarterly reports including total weights of computers, monitors, televisions, and other items covered under the law; the manufacturers to which the items were attributed to in order to attain the manufacturers’ annual recycling goals; and, a list of end markets to which the processed materials were sent, among other information. Other bills would allow municipalities and retailers to charge fees for collection. Arizona, Mississippi, New Hampshire and Massachusetts also introduced legislation to create new extended producer responsibility (EPR) programs.
Issue: Recycled Rubber/Artificial Turf
Despite the ongoing federal, state, and international studies that thus far indicate no significant risk to athletes who play on synthetic turf surfaces, state and local legislators continue to react to assertions in the media that playing on synthetic turf fields with recycled rubber infill is connected to long-term health risks. As of May 8, there were:
- 13 bills in 8 states directly targeting crumb rubber and synthetic turf;
- 5 in Maryland that authorize debt to install synthetic turf fields,
- 3 EPR bills in Connecticut, 1 in Vermont, and 2 in Massachusetts that could impact how tires can be recycled and crumb rubber utilized; and
- 1 resolution in New Mexico that would study the recycling and reuse of tires.
Illinois passed Senate Resolution 118, urging the state to create a “watchlist” of fields and playgrounds containing crumb rubber and publish it on the Illinois EPA website until federal testing concludes that crumb rubber “is definitively safe for use as infill” and urging such fields and playgrounds to provide notice to parents of the federal study and the “possible chemical exposure to their children”; however, resolutions do not carry statutory weight. Minnesota legislators slipped a 3-year moratorium on the construction of artificial turf fields into an omnibus health & human services bill just before it passed the Senate, but it was later stripped out. The bill currently awaits concurrence between the House and Senate versions. Maryland HB 1353 threatened a different approach, exposing state and local government to unlimited tort liability in claims involving artificial turf, but following testimony by Tire Division Chair Mark Rannie the House Judiciary Committee ruled against passage.
Issue: State SREA Equivalents
While all 50 states have enacted laws similar to the federal Superfund law, only seven have adopted state laws similar to the Superfund Recycling Equity Act (SREA). While the courts in various states have suggested that a party that sells a valuable “product” should not be subject to environmental cleanup cost liability, in states without a SREA equivalent it is possible that scrap processors and recyclers could potentially be subject to liability. To this end, efforts in the Southeast and Gulf Coast chapters have led to the recent adoption of state SREA equivalents in Florida and Tennessee, the passage of South Carolina SB 181 just this month, and additional bills approaching passage in North Carolina and Texas. For more information on SREA, please contact Shelley Backstrom.